Fourth edition · Created by Yoav Duman

Does a Nation Have a Birthday?

Instructor guide

I start with a museum label that gives a book and a nation the same birthday. Students decide which source to ask for first, make a prediction, and change their account when a record changes.

Where it fits

Use in introductory Comparative Politics for nationalism and causal inference. In American Government, use the federal postal-law replay and Charleston to discuss access to political information, then use the Wimmer and Müller debrief to ask whose voices count.

Prepare the assignment

Allow about 45–60 minutes for individual play. No advance reading is required. The complete guide also gives a 50-minute class plan, worked examples, source links, and alternate submission directions.

Assess the reasoning

Use the 100-point rubric for seven written responses and a 220-word combined floor. The report shows structured checks separately. Read the initial interpretation alongside the audit and the later label.

Debrief one comparison

Ask what a second document can add when it repeats the first. Then ask which dated source could tell us that someone outside the group took up the claim.