Teaching materials
The instructor guide includes pacing, discussion prompts, and the scoring rubric. The student packet gives students a printable route through the decisions and evidence.
Run the activity
Use the case in introductory comparative politics or U.S. government, in class or as independent work. Students make a recommendation, cast a vote, audit the intake records, and rerun the hearing under one changed rule. They then compare recorded actions with private priorities and apply a mechanism to a new case.
Students write six explanations and two new-case responses. GPT coaching selects one instructor-written follow-up from each saved first draft. Both coaching modes run the same case checks on the device at replay, preferences and transfer. The final check gives students a fresh condition to try before any hint on that condition. They can keep a draft that already fits or revise it in their own words. Hints and retries carry no deduction.
For a discussion of neoliberalism, start with the Board’s vendor contract and Sam’s choice about a joint request. Then use the school funding case to trace how public rules give private providers different incentives.
Assess the reasoning
Score each of five criteria from 0 to 2. A passing written report earns at least 8 out of 10 and at least one point on every criterion. Use the first drafts, case check traces and revisions to score the student’s explanations. Any policy choice or stance can earn full credit with accurate evidence and reasoning.
Optional independent transfer
Give each student a fresh set of numbers when they begin, change one fact, and ask what follows and what evidence supports it. Offer the same task orally or in brief writing. If you use it, score it separately. Give 2 for an accurate implication and specific evidence or test, 1 for one of those, and 0 for neither.