Comparative Politics / instructor guide

Who Gets the Second Crew?

I use this case to separate who belongs, who benefits and who has authority to spend public money.

Who Gets the Second Crew? Created by Yoav Duman. An orange route crosses a teal screen print of a flooded river town.

How I run it

For a 50-minute meeting, plan 6 minutes for a first response, 22 for the core simulation or staged paper case, 6 for the alternate response, 12 for debrief and 4 for collection. Use For fun if you collect the independent response separately. These are planning estimates.

  1. Ask students to choose a rule before the registry opens. Compare the decision with the forecast of what taxpayers would support.
  2. Compare the fictional dispatch ledger with the experiment on stated U.S. government aid support. Ask which finding or uncertainty supports the updated forecast.
  3. Keep the levy, guaranteed pump deployment and preferred project fixed. The advisory charter leaves the board tied 2–2 with the reserve intact. A counted vote changes the tally to 3–2 and issues the work order.
  4. At the hearing, separate residence from citizenship using matched profiles. For a full Class run, complete the new clinic case before discussion.

What I look for

When might a responsibility to residents or to contributors look like national solidarity? Which comparison would distinguish them?

Grade the written reasoning and revision separately from completion. The packet includes a 100-point case rubric and a separate eight-point transfer rubric. A checked box records a choice. The survey estimates a difference in stated support among the respondents in the comparison. Claims about actual aid and the joint fund require other evidence.

Copy for Canvas

Printable materials

Study and reading