Nationalism & citizenship

National solidarity, public aid & political voice

Who Gets the Second Crew?

Two towns qualify. There is one crew left. What makes your decision fair?

Send the last flood crew from a shared fund. Compare your dispatch with a real survey of support for government aid, then see what a counted vote can change.

How it runsSolo simulation
Time to planAbout 45–55 min for Class
What you produceA PDF or text record of decisions, first and revised claims, the ballot and the independent clinic case

For Class requires the complete Full activity and final report action before assignment printing or downloads. Core and Full length choices, where offered, are available in For Fun. Save a progress backup whenever you need to pause.

For class: download your report when you finish, then submit it through your course website. Downloading does not submit it.

This activity supports saving on this device. Check its save status before closing, and download a progress backup before changing browsers or devices.

Saving & submission →
Embed this activity

Bring the activity into your course.

Paste this snippet into an LMS or website HTML editor that supports iframes. The snippet displays the hosted activity without including its source code.

Keep the full-tab link included below the frame. Some LMSs and browsers restrict embedded storage, downloads or printing. Students should download a backup before changing views; opening a new tab does not transfer an in-memory record.

Embedding and free-use permissions →
Who Gets the Second Crew? Created by Yoav Duman. An orange route crosses a dark teal print of a flooded river town.

What you can explore

Empirical work. Interpret a published survey experiment on stated support for flood aid. The shared fund and dispatch decisions are fictional.

  • Distinguish who receives help, whose support is being measured and who can authorize spending.
  • Separate citizenship from residence using matched profiles and test rival explanations.
  • Explain what changes when the same preference becomes a counted vote.

TAKE IT WITH YOU

Keep the game. Keep your questions.

Play online or download the self-contained HTML game. No installation or student account is needed.

For Class, complete Full and assemble the report before printing or exporting the assignment. A progress backup lets you pause or move devices; downloading does not submit work.

What the model leaves open

Alder, Venn and the fund records are fictional. The published survey measures stated support for U.S. government aid. A separate study would be needed for the joint fund.

AFTERWARD, THINK ABOUT

When might a duty to residents or contributors look like national solidarity?

Teaching this activity Debrief, assessment & assignment draft

Bring it back to the room

  • When might a duty to residents or contributors look like national solidarity?
  • What evidence supports changing or keeping your forecast for the joint fund?
  • How did the vote change what Marl District could authorize?

What to assess

Read the written reasons beside the vote and comparison records. Use the instructor packet’s 100-point case rubric and separate eight-point transfer rubric. Score the first unaided clinic response.

Read the complete teaching guide →

Syllabus description, rubric & printable companion →

Prepare an assignment to share.

Edit this text, then copy it into Canvas or your course website. These edits stay in this tab.

Syllabus description & discussion prompts

Syllabus description

Send the last flood crew from a shared fund. Compare your dispatch with a real survey of support for government aid, then see what a counted vote can change. Students produce a pdf or text record of decisions, first and revised claims, the ballot and the independent clinic case.

Questions for a discussion board or class debrief

  1. When might a duty to residents or contributors look like national solidarity?
  2. What evidence supports changing or keeping your forecast for the joint fund?
  3. How did the vote change what Marl District could authorize?
Open printable teaching companion →