TEACHING COMPANION / NO ACCOUNT NEEDED
What Counts?
Three tutoring pilots compete for $12,000. Who gets a vote, and which options get a hearing?
Dimensions of power, institutional rules & evidence · About 70–75 min
Empirical work. Use published experiments, a student survey and institutional records to evaluate reasoning about tutoring access, then test a mechanism with evidence from work scheduling or job advertisements. The Cedar Reach budget and advising records are fictional.
Learning goals
- Use vote totals to distinguish binding authority from advisory influence.
- Trace how counting and hearing rules change which options reach a ballot while voter rankings stay fixed.
- Distinguish the role an institution invites students to take, the action it records and what students privately prioritize.
- Apply a mechanism to a real case and identify evidence that could distinguish rival explanations.
Seven steps, one individual report.
Assign the seven-step simulation individually. Students write six explanations, work through two new-case checks and assemble a PDF or text report. Use the activity’s rubric to grade the reasoning and transfer memo.
Before the activity
The simulation includes the case records, source cards and definitions. No advance reading is required.
Syllabus description
Join the budget committee at fictional Cedar Reach College. Vote on three tutoring pilots, audit which student requests were counted, and replay one hearing rule. Use published studies and institutional records to test your reasoning in a new case. Students produce an individual pdf or text report with decision records, selected claims, written explanations and a transfer memo..
Discussion prompts
- What can change when a proposal gains a hearing and the funding decision stays the same?
- What later evidence would help distinguish a change in recorded actions from a lasting change in priorities?
What to assess
Students complete built-in selected-claim checks and write their own reasoning on fresh cases. Report readiness means the required responses are recorded. Use the instructor rubric to assess the explanations and transfer memo.
Limitations
Cedar Reach, its budget and the planner comparison are fictional. The published records describe specific settings and outcomes. College-wide demand and lasting changes in priorities would require further evidence.
Credit & permissions
Created by Yoav Duman. Free educational use, sharing and hosted embedding; software rights reserved. Software, artwork, branding and third-party materials are separate; see the full reuse information.
Suggested citation: Yoav Duman, “What Counts?: Teaching companion,” Possible States, https://possiblestates.com/teaching/what-counts. Include your access date.
Prepare an assignment to share.
Edit this text, then copy it into Canvas or your course website. These edits stay in this tab.
Syllabus description & discussion prompts
Syllabus description
Join the budget committee at fictional Cedar Reach College. Vote on three tutoring pilots, audit which student requests were counted, and replay one hearing rule. Use published studies and institutional records to test your reasoning in a new case. Students produce an individual pdf or text report with decision records, selected claims, written explanations and a transfer memo..
Questions for a discussion board or class debrief
- What can change when a proposal gains a hearing and the funding decision stays the same?
- What later evidence would help distinguish a change in recorded actions from a lasting change in priorities?