POSSIBLE STATES / TEACHING GUIDE
Teach with the simulations.
Find a setup, a discussion prompt and a way to assess the work for each activity.
Choosing an activity
Empirical means students interpret real data, primary records or findings from published empirical studies to support or check a claim. Some activities also use clearly labeled fictional materials. An empirical extension identifies a separate, optional real-evidence exercise.
Explore empirical simulations →
A classroom routine
- Assign an endpoint and the work students should turn in. Use the activity’s guide for its report and submission steps.
- Ask students to preserve a forecast and a reason before revealing a result or opening a second source.
- In discussion, ask which record changed the answer and what evidence could support another explanation.
Main collection and Evidence Lab
Citizen on Which Roll?
On the Record
Does a Nation Have a Birthday?
Who Gets the Second Crew?
The Quiet Map
- Set up the activity
- Put up the producer’s three words “quieter,” “because” and “chose.” Let students mark one before you define the relevant outcome for them. Reserve 10–15 minutes for the debrief after 30–40 minutes of independent Class play.
- Ask in the debrief
- Have two students read different defensible first sentences. Who or what does each sentence count? What would let a reporter say something about the people who moved?
- What to assess
- Use the four-part 100-point rubric. Look for accurate source use, a real rival to the causal story and a bounded revision in Åland. Read the first and final filings together.
- Source and scope
- Teach ethnic nationalism and its consequences critically, without endorsing ethnic nationalism or forced displacement. Government dispute counts and household security are distinct outcomes.
Who Will Fight to Keep It?
- Set up the activity
- Assign the Comparative politics lens. Have students hold the contact list constant as they compare two relief plans, then hold the actual Millhaven signatures constant as they change the hearing rule.
- Ask in the debrief
- How can two petitions with the same number of signatures get different hearings? What published finding informs the first comparison you would make in two actual places?
- What to assess
- Use the four Class responses. Check the trace from eligibility through contact to signing, the correct application of both hearing rules, and the proposed comparable measure.
- Source and scope
- The published studies inform students’ research designs. Riverford and Millhaven supply designed comparisons of program rules and participation.
Why Open the Rules?
- Set up the activity
- Assign at least two countries before students open Class. Ask them to lock one initial forecast per case before opening the historical record. Use the course’s own deadline for the cross-case comparison and Orvessa transfer.
- Ask in the debrief
- Find two cases where the ruling side accepted an opening. What made a possible loss tolerable in one case, and what makes that mechanism uncertain in the other?
- What to assess
- Require a named actor, dated decision, correct denominator and one supported revision. Ask what observed behavior would distinguish risk reduction from the rival account.
- Source and scope
- The opening choices are modeled. Historical outcomes and public reasons support bounded claims about the selected cases.
Why Here? The Prosperity Puzzle
- Set up the activity
- Ask students to predict which comparison will make their preferred explanation look weakest. Have them keep that case in the report and label country, year and unit next to every reported number.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which comparison is awkward for a single-factor explanation? What could tell us whether geography affected prosperity directly or through an institutional mechanism?
- What to assess
- Look for a matched or deliberately contrasting case, one appropriately scoped result from a study, a rival mechanism and a remaining ambiguity.
- Source and scope
- Country comparisons are descriptive. Different published designs bear on different parts of the argument about prosperity.
Who Catches You?
- Set up the activity
- Start with the same financial shock across the four modeled households. Pause before the country evidence and have students write a prediction from each explanation of redistribution.
- Ask in the debrief
- When does needing protection fail to produce access? When can many people prefer a policy and still lack the organization to win it?
- What to assess
- Grade the mechanism from eligibility or organization to an outcome, one accurately dated country comparison and the implication of an alternative explanation.
- Source and scope
- Household outcomes are modeled. Real country figures are dated and separately rank income and net wealth.
The Power Circuit
- Set up the activity
- Stop after the matched system runs, the nine country dossiers and the research synthesis. Have students mark the office, constitutional provision and consequence at each transition.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which government could survive the same loss on a bill? Which actor can remove it, under what provision, and how could you observe the rule’s effects in practice?
- What to assess
- Require correct citation of an actual institutional rule, a counterfactual that changes one condition and a feasible test of the hypothesized consequence.
- Source and scope
- Constitutions document authorized procedures. The crises, votes and officeholder responses are hypothetical applications.
The Square
- Set up the activity
- Run the 20-person participation problem and compare one replay that changes a single condition. Assign the optional Right2Water panel when students should use observed initiative data.
- Ask in the debrief
- What stops a person who supports the cause from joining? Why can the same signature total qualify under one geographic rule and miss under another?
- What to assess
- Check the direction of the changed condition, the evidence from the replay and the explanation of a change in response. For Right2Water, require both valid signatures and national thresholds.
- Source and scope
- The main rounds model participation. The extension uses actual European initiative counts with a counterfactual rule that holds signatures fixed.
The Order Was Given
- Set up the activity
- Ask students to forecast two organizations’ responses before opening the replies. Compare the access-only replay with the original and list everything deliberately held fixed.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which parts of the order worked through public authority? Which outcomes still depended on an organization committing its own resources?
- What to assess
- Look for an observable resource decision, a clear comparison and a bounded conclusion about access or campaign opportunities.
- Source and scope
- Lydora is a designed setting for studying opportunity under unequal competition. Its available choices and results are modeled.
Manytide
- Set up the activity
- Start from the household’s immediate service problem. Ask students to keep a list of who writes the rule, who supplies money and who has to travel or wait. Reuse it in the new case.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which change moved the bottleneck? Whose problem remains when the relevant regions negotiate a common rule?
- What to assess
- Check the mechanism from divided authority to one concrete household consequence. Require an explanation of what the matched comparison holds constant.
- Source and scope
- The federation and archives are authored fiction. The design isolates a mechanism connecting political boundaries, belonging and usable services.
After the Count
- Set up the activity
- Ask every student to label the first result with its unit before comparing rules. Then hold the recorded votes fixed and trace how the rule converts them into seats, advancement or victory.
- Ask in the debrief
- What can two rules do with the same ballots? Which part of a prediction about voter or party strategy would need a different analysis?
- What to assess
- Grade correct rule application, valid denominator, explicit fixed-vote assumption and one plausible behavioral response needing evidence.
- Source and scope
- The election results are historical. Alternative counting rules use those ballots for a controlled replay.
The Overloaded State
- Set up the activity
- Plan separate work blocks for the reading, implementation chain and hearing. Require students to follow the same user or application through the record before recommending a reform.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which decision made the promise official? Where did the chain stall? What change would show the bottleneck moved while applicants kept a usable appeal?
- What to assess
- Require a cited bottleneck, a complicating record, accurate use of one published finding and an outcome that can be measured after reform.
- Source and scope
- Published studies illuminate implementation and administrative constraints. The Riverbend records and follow-up comparison are designed for the inquiry.
The Hearing
- Set up the activity
- Begin with a sealed hypothesis and rival. Before students review a second case, have them place two dated records against the first case’s explanation and identify the strongest complication.
- Ask in the debrief
- What distinguishes evidence of restricted competition from evidence of an opposition that simply disappointed voters?
- What to assess
- Require two accurately described dated cards, one genuine complication and an observation that would favor the rival. Score the comparison and revision.
- Source and scope
- The case files use real events and sources. Each dated observation covers a specific place, decision or period.
The Shared Country
- Set up the activity
- Assign the shared river problem first. Before the final policies, have students mark what is constitutionally protected, what is delegated and what requires agreement over money.
- Ask in the debrief
- Who can block a decision, and who carries its cost? How does this answer change when a minority lives inside a region with protected powers?
- What to assess
- Trace one earlier assignment of authority through flood, clinic or licensing implementation. Require a named tradeoff.
- Source and scope
- The core exercise is a fictional federation. Canada and India offer comparative constitutional references for follow-up.
Greenovia: The Belonging Test
- Set up the activity
- Have students write the key charter rules before they inspect the household consequences. End with one rewrite and a prediction about which burden remains.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which right was promised on paper? Show one place where a language, residence, schooling or voting rule determined who could use it.
- What to assess
- Look for an exact clause, a linked household outcome, a feasible revision and a tradeoff the revision leaves open.
- Source and scope
- The households and charter options are designed scenarios for linking nationhood, citizenship and institutional design.
A Door That Says Open
- Set up the activity
- Record the first access judgment. Have students change one rule, then apply the contrast to a documented real case. The supplied Malawi 2019–2020 record is available.
- Ask in the debrief
- When does a formal right turn into usable access? Who controls timing or administration in the comparison case, and who still faces a barrier?
- What to assess
- Check the named barrier, affected actor, causal sequence and specific similarity and difference in the sourced case.
- Source and scope
- The early voting, campaigning and accountability scenarios are fictional. Full Class work includes a real-case transfer.
Protection, Inc.: The Price of Power
- Set up the activity
- Let students bargain first, then replace the leader. Have them identify one thing that continued and one thing that depended on the first leader’s enforcement or resources.
- Ask in the debrief
- What makes protection predictable? If people keep paying, what evidence would tell us whether they consent or see few alternatives?
- What to assess
- Require a specific enforcement or extraction mechanism, an outcome across leaders and one observation that could support a claim about legitimacy.
- Source and scope
- The bargains are invented. Payments and compliance inside the game can illustrate institutional continuity.
The Repression Trap
- Set up the activity
- Before each reveal, ask students to forecast visibility, participation or consequential noncooperation. Save the first forecast and compare a changed-setting replay.
- Ask in the debrief
- When does attention rise while organizing becomes harder? What would count as an organization actually withdrawing cooperation?
- What to assess
- Grade the evidence for a sequence connecting an action to an actor’s behavior. Ask for a route by which the same response can mobilize one group and silence another.
- Source and scope
- Lydora and its indicators are designed. The published-source notes ground discussion of civil resistance and the limits of generalization.
Everyone Says Democracy
- Set up the activity
- Plan several work blocks. Ask students to predict what agreement with the label means, compare the studies, then test exact practices and candidate choices in the designed case.
- Ask in the debrief
- What does the person call democratic? What do they choose when a practice has a cost? How would you distinguish wording from a change in political preference?
- What to assess
- Require a concept, an indicator, a precise study result and a revised measure or question that addresses a named validity problem.
- Source and scope
- The research findings have country, timing and design limits. The game’s survey responses and party decisions are simulated.
When the Center Breaks
- Set up the activity
- Assign a cross-case pair and have students put their outcome threshold in writing early. Require a dated timeline and a turning point before allowing them to classify change.
- Ask in the debrief
- When did a leader leave? What changed in the distribution of authority, and which evidence would show whether social relations changed too?
- What to assess
- Look for an accurate threshold, a named actor and mechanism, a complicating dated record and a defensible comparison.
- Source and scope
- The four cases use historical evidence. Outcome labels depend on definitions and the observation period.
Name the Problem
- Set up the activity
- Choose congressional representation or global regime classification. Ask students to write the denominator before the headline, then publish a revised poster after the challenge.
- Ask in the debrief
- How do the answer and political frame change when we count people or seats, use a benchmark, or ask whether a trend is large enough to matter?
- What to assess
- Grade numeric accuracy, data-to-claim warrant, clarity about the value threshold and performance on the new transfer graph.
- Source and scope
- The first inquiry uses Pew or V-Dem data. The new transfer charts are invented.
Hold the Headline
- Set up the activity
- Give the editor two record slots. Require a reason for each request before the reveal. Allow a bounded headline or a documented decision to hold.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which record speaks to implementation? What would be the cheapest discriminating record between two still-plausible bridge explanations?
- What to assess
- Grade the information value of each request and the match between final wording and what the edited record establishes.
- Source and scope
- The bridge and records are designed practice. Use the newsroom choices to discuss evidentiary limits.
The Evidence Lab
- Set up the activity
- Work café and navigation examples independently, then compare two possible rival explanations. Have students save their own design and finish the unfamiliar challenge before inspecting optional hints.
- Ask in the debrief
- What explains the pooled pattern? What data or comparison would distinguish a proposed mechanism from selection into the busier group?
- What to assess
- Read the five-part plan for a testable question, credible rival, discriminating evidence and predicted results. Use the final challenge as a separate check.
- Source and scope
- All case observations are fictional. The laboratory gives students controlled practice in evidence selection and comparison.
Frontiers research simulations
The Democracy Alarm
- Set up the activity
- Block time for study comparison, indicators and the independent audit. Have students commit necessary conditions and comparison weights before opening the difficult case.
- Ask in the debrief
- What does a country-weighted summary answer? What protection can disappear in a population-weighted average even when the average looks informative?
- What to assess
- Require the two real research arguments, an explicitly justified measure and a dated Bellara mechanism that survives a rival and a fresh dossier.
- Source and scope
- The published backsliding debate is real. The Bellara documents and exact tables are composed for the simulation.
The Civic Machine
- Set up the activity
- Before discussing the research, ask students what it would mean for AI to speak for a group. Compare the studies, make a design choice for the transit meeting, and test the safeguard in a second institution.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which measured outcome concerns endorsement, which concerns movement in opinion, and which information would show whose voice shaped the recommendation?
- What to assess
- Grade accurate interpretation of one result, a workable participation safeguard and an observable threshold that would justify using it or changing it.
- Source and scope
- The AI results belong to particular research designs. The public consultation and local documents are fictional.
The Persuasion Hearing
- Set up the activity
- Have students extract a comparison and an outcome from the experiments before writing a licensing rule. Commit the evidence request before opening the local response.
- Ask in the debrief
- What do the studies measure about immediate persuasion? What observation would justify a claim about sustained belief, voting or public harm?
- What to assess
- Require an accurate comparison group and outcome, a rival explanation, a proportionate rule and a credible follow-up test.
- Source and scope
- Published experiments supply measured effects in study settings. The municipal application is a designed case.
Major Decisions
- Set up the activity
- Open the two studies before the first firm claim. Ask students to draw a timing sequence for prior preferences, study choice, an educational experience and later political behavior.
- Ask in the debrief
- Which evidence could distinguish prior sorting into a major from effects of study or later work? How would attendance and field of study enter different comparisons?
- What to assess
- Check how accurately the report matches each design to its actual claim, interprets a rival, and predicts a separating observation in the new case.
- Source and scope
- The research designs and outcomes come from published studies. The decision and institutional records in play are fictional.